top of page
Search

Twist Rate: Part II - Deeper Understanding

Nov 8
6 min read

From the Overwatch Podcast: Episode XXIII - Twist Rate



Remington 700 5R 300BLK w/ Magpul Chassis
Remington 700 5R 300BLK w/ Magpul Chassis


One of the first “long-range” rifles I built was based on the idea that if I wanted a truly quiet “sniper rifle,” I would need to shoot subsonic ammunition. What better rifle to build than a 300 Blackout bolt-action rifle? This was right as the 300BLK was gaining popularity. I picked up a Remington 700 5R in 300blk. Over the years, this barreled action went from one stock to another until it finally rested in a Magpul chassis. The reason I bring this up is that this has been a rifle that I learned the basics of long-range shooting on. This is the rifle that has also had me chasing my tail for accuracy. In fact, a few years ago, out of nowhere, I was getting 8-10 MOA at 100 yards. Something is wrong!! I got new dies, new brass, and tried ladder testing from minimum to maximum load data. Funny thing was, the slower the bullet, the better the accuracy. Yet I could still get good groups with subsonics at 100 yards. I put the rifle away, and it sadly sat in the safe for years. A few weeks ago, I thought to myself, I am much more knowledgeable now; let's figure out the problem.



Range trip


I loaded 50 rounds: 25 with 16.8 grains of H110 under a 110 Hornady V-Max, and 25 with 19.5 grains. To my surprise, with 16.8 grains and a velocity of 1,930, I was shooting sub-MOA groups at 100 yards. I shot 5, 5-shot groups, all sub-MOA. I couldn't understand it; this made no sense. Next, I shot the 19.5-grain loads (2,400 fps) and got a six-inch group. I shot 2 more 5-round groups and got the same result. I took notes, brought my targets home, and got to work figuring out what the hell was going on. I checked everything:

Rail, scope, Scope mounts, Scope screws, action screws, barrel torque, bolt, lugs, chamber, barrel, lands and grooves, and everything looked good. I trusted myself and the rifle and decided it wasn't the rifle. So, it has to be the bullet. The problem with blaming the bullet is that it shot fine at around 1,900 fps it shot fine, so it has to do with the bullet vs. speed. The only thing that controls the bullet in this situation is velocity and twist rate, as I have eliminated all other factors. I got on to Strelok Pro, selected my 300 BLK profile, and checked the gyroscopic stability factor (GSF) of the 110 Hornady V-Max at 2400 fps. It was an astonishing 7.39!! I also confirmed it with Berger's stability calculator.


To successfully stabilize a bullet, you need a minimum GSF of 1.5. Once a bullet is stable, you can't make it more stable. Next, I checked the RPM rate and found the bullet is spinning at 252,000 RPM. That's fast.


FYI, here is how to calculate RPM


Calculation:

  • Velocity: 2,450 feet per second (fps)

  • Twist Rate: 1 turn per 7 inches

  • Revolutions per second: 2,450 (fps) / (7 / 12 ft) = 4,200 (turns per second)

  • Revolutions per minute: (4,200 x 60 = 252,000 (RPM)


Or Google it.


A quick Google search says the thin-jacketed varmint bullets can sometimes tear themselves apart mid-air if spun too fast (usually approaching 290,000–300,000+ RPM). I checked the RPM of the slower 16.8 grain load at 1,900 fps and got around 200,000 RPM. I have finally found the issue after all these years. The bullet is deforming from being spun too much. To show you how much, let's compare this data to my 6.5 Creedmoor bullets.


A 6.5 Creedmoor with a 1:8 twist and a 147 ELD-M at 2,670 FPS gives me a GSF of 1.65 at 241,200 rpm. Keep in mind, match bullets can handle higher RPM because of the much thicker copper jacket.


My next journey with this rifle is to find a longer, heavier hunting bullet.



Cast Lead Bullets with Modern Fast Twist Rates


Every 4 years, we see the same thing in politics: Anti-gun rhetoric. This leads to panic buying of arms, ammunition, bullets, primers, and powder. I refuse to fall victim to the nonsense. This type of environment led me on a journey to cast subsonic lead bullets so I can continue to shoot my long-range rifles without having to use my finite resources during these times. Long story short, I was working on load development with subsonic 6.5 Creedmoor and .338 Lapua Magnum. Because I can cast my own bullets, I can safely use just a few grains of a certain powder and cheap primers I have on hand for these rounds, costing just around 4 to 6 cents per round. I also thought it would be a good idea to have a very slow, supersonic cast-lead load as well. As I was working up a load around 1,500 to 1,600 fps, I got a baffle strike on my silencer. This led me down the path of velocity vs. twist rate with cast bullets. During my research, I found that cast bullets can't handle the speeds or twist rates of modern jacketed bullets. Below is an RPM and twist rate diagram. This shows exactly what went wrong.




Cast Lead Bullet RPM & Twist Rate Chart
Cast Lead Bullet RPM & Twist Rate Chart



As you can see in the chart above, with a 1:8 twist at 1,600 fps, the RPM of the cast lead bullet is around 144,00 rpm. The maximum safe RPM (rotations per minute) threshold for traditional cast lead bullets generally falls in the 120,000 to 140,000 RPM range. Just like the situation above, I'm spinning the bullet too fast due to high velocity. The answer in this situation is to slow the bullet to 1,500 fps or slower.


In both situations, you can see how the faster twist rate affected the bullet to the point of catastrophic failure. While both situations are rare, it's worth checking the GSF and RPMs with every bullet you shoot, but especially small varmint rounds and cast bullets.



Slow Twist Rate


In the infancy of my long-range shooting, before I was educated on things such as twist rate, i focused solely on how far a bullet could accurately travel. Meaning I was selecting a bullet only based on the distance it was able to remain supersonic, and nothing else. At that time, I was shooting a Remington 700 5R Gen II in .308 Winchester with an 11.25 twist rate. I chose a Hornady 208-grain A-Max. I tested 3 or 4 different powders from minimum to maximum grain weight, in .3-grain increments, with consistent accuracy of about 1.3 to 1.5 MOA at 100 yards. I’ll tell you straight up, the twist rate was too slow. Let's look at the data.


The 208-grain A-max in 308, running about 2,550 FPS with an 11.25 twist rate, gives me 162,560 RPM with a GSF of 1.2. Because the bullet pitches and yaws (from such a low GSF) as it flies rather than tracking perfectly straight, it experiences more aerodynamic drag. In a sub-marginal stability state, you can expect to lose roughly 3% to 5% or more of your effective Ballistic Coefficient, causing it to drop faster and at longer distances than ballistic apps predict, and to have less accuracy and precision.


With a twist rate that's too slow, you will also have what’s called Atmospheric Vulnerability. This refers to the increased sensitivity of bullet stability to environmental changes, especially air density. Cold, dense air increases aerodynamic overturning torque, which is the force that tries to tip the bullet off its axis as it spins through the air. In warmer, thinner air, like on a hot summer day (85°F) or at high elevation, the bullet is more stable, and the gyroscopic stability factor (Sg) might rise to a safer margin, around 1.35–1.40, reducing the risk of instability. However, if you take this exact same load and shoot it on a freezing winter morning (20°F) or at sea level, where the air is much denser, the bullet experiences more overturning torque. The increased air density can push the Sg down to marginal levels, possibly 1.10 or lower. When Sg drops this low, the bullet may begin to yaw or wobble significantly, causing it to veer off course and drastically open up your groups, turning what was a precise load into a poor performer just from a change in weather or location. This is why loads that are only marginally stable can be unpredictable, and why it’s crucial to build in a stability buffer for real-world conditions, not just ideal ones.


In summary, understanding twist rate and how it interacts with bullet construction, velocity, and atmospheric conditions is essential for accuracy and reliability in any rifle. My journey with the 300 Blackout and .308 has shown just how sensitive bullets can be to both underspin and overspin, and how quickly a load that works perfectly in one scenario can fall apart in another. Whether you are chasing sub-MOA groups or just want consistent performance, always factor in stability margins and real-world conditions when selecting components and developing loads. The science behind twist rate isn’t just theory; it’s a practical tool that can save you endless frustration and help you get the most out of your rifle on any day, anywhere.


Overwatch

 
 
 

Comments


Subscribe Form

Thanks for submitting!

1776 Freedom Street, USA

  • Facebook
  • YouTube

©2020 by The Overwatch. Proudly created with Wix.com

bottom of page